The James White Information Site

Answer Came There None

First published
1974
Words
7,500

Like a green and seemingly virginal carpet, the planetary surface unrolled five miles below the slowing ship.

The title derives from Alice Through the Looking-Glass: “But answer came there none/And this was scarcely odd, because/They’d eaten every one.” Jan and pater are a married-couple Terran searchship crew making their second visit in umpteen years to an unfortunately lon-dead extrasolar planet. They eventually get some half-answers to the question of why long-lived, stable, and technologically advanced civilizations so often come to a hard end. I can detect a strong, if gender-transposed, link between them and J(ames) and P(eggy) White. “Suddenly they were hugging each other, a ridiculous and senseless thing to do considering the thickness of their suits. But it did not matter.”

Synopsis by
Graham Andrews

In magazines

Title Language Editor Date
Galaxy, January 1974 cover
Galaxy, January 1974 English Ejler Jakobsson January 1974

In anthologies

Title Editor Year
The Best from Galaxy 3 cover
The Best from Galaxy 3 James Baen 1975
Science-Fiction-Stories 73 cover
Science-Fiction-Stories 73 Uncredited 1978
Sterren van Galaxy III cover
Sterren van Galaxy III Uncredited 1982

In James White's books

Title Type Year
Monsters and Medics, Corgi Books / Transworld Publishers, 1977 cover
Monsters and Medics Collection 1977
Publication notes

GALAXY January 1974 THE BEST FROM GALAXY 3, ed James Baen, Award Book, 1975 Monsters and Medics

Data sources
James White Information (original site). Synopsis by Graham Andrews.
ISFDB title record (CC BY 4.0).