The James White Information Site

Question of Cruelty

First published
1956
Words
5,250

The great flying wing, its controls sluggish in the high, rarefied air, came slowly out of the dive and pulled its nose up in a forty-five degree climb.

"We have been judge and executioner to many planets such as this. Very few have not been found wanting and allowed to survive. This one will be given exactly what it deserves . . ." So sayeth Srilla, hanging-judge captain of an alien Execution Ship, about the latest planetary case on his docket. He must figure out Earth's first spacebeing, who bears only an evolutionary relationship to Yuri Gagarin. The last line almost, but not quite, matches that from A.E. van Vogt's 'Recruitng Station' (Astounding, February 1942), aka Masters of Time and Earth's Last Fortress.

Synopsis by
Graham Andrews

In magazines

Title Language Editor Date
New Worlds 44, February 1956 cover
New Worlds 44, February 1956 English John Carnell February 1956

In James White's books

Title Type Year
Futures Past, Del Rey / Ballantine, 1982 cover
Futures Past Collection 1982
Publication notes

NEW WORLDS No 44, February 1956

Publication History: Futures Past

Data sources
James White Information (original site). Synopsis by Graham Andrews.
ISFDB title record (CC BY 4.0).